Politics / Whistleblowers

An Open Letter to Major General Buchanan

ImageProxy.mvcMajor General Buchanan:

Sir, you have the power to do the right thing and make sure that Bradley Manning is commended for his actions, not thrown in jail for the rest of his life.

Manning exposed war crimes. Whether or not those war crimes were confidential should have no bearing in this instance. “If you see something, say something” is plastered on every bus and train that I ride every day. As civilians, if we see something dangerous or wrong, we are asked to speak up and do our civil service for our fellow citizens. Bradley Manning saw something and he spoke up, even in the face of his own danger. What, I ask you, is the difference between Manning speaking up for justice and safety, and an every day citizen doing just that? The crimes that Manning exposed have not put us in danger. The war crimes that were committed put us in danger. Grave danger. The world already knows what atrocities the U.S. is committing around the globe. People with family members and friends that were victims of drone attacks or other atrocities like the Collateral Murder Video that Manning released are already aware of crimes being committed in the name of the United States. But the people of the United States have been ignorant to these issues for too long. Bradley Manning changed that when he brought these documents to light.

Bradley Manning has forced us to confront our own failings in the global war on terror. He has sparked a much needed debate around the world on what actions are acceptable during war time. He has shown us the true cost of war – shown us that it is not the clean and surgical war that many of those in power would have us believe. War is bloody. War is dirty. These are things Manning has forced us to talk about. Without an informed public, without debate, democracy cannot function. A secretive and covert government cannot be held accountable, and a government that is not held accountable to the people will eventually sicken and die.

Manning is a hero. That is clear. The question is, Major General Buchanan, are you a hero or a coward? Stand up for the right thing. Stand on the right side of history. Free Bradley Manning.

Thank you.


Alyssa Röhricht
Citizen of the World
I am Bradley Manning.

Please send your own letter to jeffrey.s.buchanan@us.army.mil or call at 202-685-2900.

2 thoughts on “An Open Letter to Major General Buchanan

  1. Personally I haven’t made up my mind about this conviction yet.
    For now, I just ponder the consequences of his leaks, they are huge.

    Did you know that Manning actually indirectly caused the arab spring?!

    He leaked diplomatic cables which indicated that the US was less supportive of the Tunesian president Ben Ali than they appeared.
    This strengthened the people of Tunesia in their resolve to get rid of their president.
    Eventually they managed to chase him out of the country and the arab spring got on it’s way.

    • Yes, I did know about Manning’s connection to the Arab Spring, specifically with regards to Tunisia. That’s just one more reason to applaud this man, not punish him. He, in part, gave the Tunisian (and consequentially many other Arab peoples) people the spark they needed to overthrow a repressive government. The implications of the leaks are huge and have sparked WORLD WIDE change and debate. Truly an amazing thing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s